The Rev. Jeffrey D. Lang, minister at the First Presbyterian Church of Glendale, Ohio
The Christian’s fundamental and unique claim is that God has spoken to human beings.1 Further, what God has disclosed has been comprehended, understood, written down, and believed. That is the heart of what propositional revelation means: Scripture does not merely point toward God in some oblique fashion, or only record subjective human experiences of him. In today’s parlance, we might say the Bible isn’t about vibes. Rather, Scripture communicates true statements from God about himself, the world, and us. Those true statements are propositions.
Carl. F.H. Henry explained it this way, “For evangelical orthodoxy, if God’s revelational disclosure to chosen prophets and apostles is to be considered meaningful and true, it must be given not merely in isolated concepts capable of diverse meanings but in sentences or propositions. A proposition – that is, a subject, predicate, and connecting verb (or ‘copula’) – constitute the minimal logical unit of intelligible communication. The Old Testament prophetic formula ‘Thus saith the Lord’ characteristically introduced propositionally disclosed truth. Jesus Christ employed the distinctive formula ‘But I say unto you’ to introduce logically-formed sentences which he represented as the veritable word or doctrine of God.”2
Some theologians prefer to say that revelation is personal rather than propositional. They assert that God reveals himself, not information. That distinction may sound pious or intellectually sophisticated, but it collapses under a more considered examination. If you take away sentences; if you remove propositions, you have only silence.
Propositional revelation is both personal and informative. Relational trust can rest on the firm foundation that the one who has spoken has spoken a sure and certain word.
Scripture works just that way. “In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth” is a sentence with content. It is a proposition. So is “Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures.” There is another proposition. The Apostle Paul did not treat the gospel as an ineffable feeling, an emotion that could not be put into words, or a personal relationship indescribable to and undecipherable by others. Instead, Paul treated the gospel as a message that could be received, believed, defended, and, so far as that goes, distorted by its enemies. Over and against the idea that the words of the Bible are unimportant, Jesus himself argued from the grammar of a text of Scripture, basing his argument on so small a matter as the tense of a verb (Matthew 22:32).
Having said this much, a caveat. None of this reduces Scripture to a bare list of propositions. The Bible is a library of writings in varied genres. The Bible contains, among other genres: poetry, history, lament, song, story, proverb, and apocalyptic among them. But every discrete genre still communicates a particular meaning. The Bible in its various writings conveys meaningful content. For instance, an apostle’s letter to a first-century congregation can communicate timeless truths about the nature of love.3
The practical importance for Christians, and for everyone, is significant. If God has not spoken in words, then every claim anyone makes about God is finally a guess, or a human projection (à la Feuerbach) onto the empty and indifferent universe. In that case, the loudest or most insistent voice in the room wins, regardless of whether what it declares is actually true. If God has spoken, then we have something to stand on, an epistemic foundation, that is not ourselves. Only a word from outside the human condition and experience can correct and guide us toward our best selves and a better tomorrow. It is that word that informs how we might “glorify God and enjoy him forever.”4
- Rousas John Rushdoony, The Word of Flux: Modern Man and the Problem of Knowledge (Fairfax, VA: Thoburn Press, 1975), p. 68: “Prior to the Christian era, there was no purported revelation outside the Scriptures. What we call ‘the sacred books of the East’ made no claim for themselves that is comparable to the idea of revelation. Since these books did not begin with a sovereign and omnipotent God, they had no word coming from such a God. The ‘sacred books of the East’ are religious and philosophical writings, some of them atheistic, but they are not revelations. Only after the beginning of the Christian era do we get ostensible revelations, in clear imitation of Scripture, such as the Koran and the Book of Mormon. The idea of a revealed word is Biblical. Only a sovereign, omnipotent, predestinating God can speak an infallible word, and the idea of such a God and such a word is not present outside the Biblical tradition.” ↩︎
- Carl F. H. Henry, “The Authority of the Bible,” in The Origin of the Bible, ed. Philip Wesley Comfort (Wheaton, IL: Tyndale House, 1992), p. 18. ↩︎
- Michael J. Langford, The Tradition of Liberal Theology (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2014), pp. 22-23. ↩︎
- Westminster Shorter Catechism, Q. 1, in The Constitution of the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.), Part I: Book of Confessions (Louisville: Office of the General Assembly, 2016), 7.001, https://www.pcusa.org/resource/book-of-confessions. ↩︎
